Julien Benda’s classic study of s Europe resonates today. The “treason of the intellectuals” is a phrase that evokes much but is inherently ambiguous. Other articles where The Treason of the Intellectuals is discussed: Julien Benda: La Trahison des clercs (; The Treason of the Intellectuals; also published . Treason of the Intellectuals (). When Machiavelli advises the Prince to carry out the Machiavellian scheme of action, he invests those actions with no.
|Published (Last):||20 November 2004|
|PDF File Size:||16.60 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||7.13 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Unfortunately, it does not do so an an sufficiently metaphysically useful way.
The Treason of the Intellectuals | work by Benda |
How ignorant we are! Julien benda treason of the intellectuals obvious law of human substance is the conquest of things and the exaltation of the impulses which secure this conquest. For them, the act which makes the State strong is invested with a moral character by the fact that it does so, and this whatever the act may be.
Gwi von Galois rated it it was amazing Jun 09, I read Indonesian version, -Pengkhiantan Kaum Cendikiawan.
Treaxon shows that the desire to be practical has become general, that the claim to be so has now become necessary in order to obtain an audience, and that the very notion of “clerkdom” has become obscured even in those who still tend to exercise that function.
And too many scholars seem prepared to support the new dispensation. More julien benda treason of the intellectuals more, intellectuals were abandoning their attachment to the traditional panoply of philosophical and scholarly ideals. References to this book The genealogy of demons: What discoveries will be made!
Orpheus could not aspire to charm the wild beasts with his music until the end of time. This contradiction was an honor to the human species, and treasn the rift whereby julien benda treason of the intellectuals slipped into the world.
None of these great heads, despite my repeated attempts to engage them, were prepared even to attempt an answer. Still, there is something respectable about pointing this out, and it would seem to me that in a ot world, this is the kind of argument that is often offered in opposition to scientifically and ethically relativist postmodernist propositions. When the distinction between culture and entertainment is obliterated, high art is orphaned, exiled from the only context in which its distinctive meaning can manifest itself: Paperbackpages.
Tolga Ju,ien rated it it was amazing Aug 14, Jun 21, Eva Sevrin rated it really liked it.
The Treason of the Intellectuals
ontellectuals Hannah Chamberlain rated it really liked it Aug 13, This is not disinterested! And my predictions are not rendered less probable by the fact that these two nations are hailed as models throughout the world by those who desire either the grandeur of their nation or the triumph of their julien benda treason of the intellectuals.
It will be seen that I entirely dissociate myself from those who want the “clerk” to govern the world, and who wish with Renan for the “reign of the philosopher”; for it seems to me that human affairs can only adopt the julien benda treason of the intellectuals of the true “clerk” under penalty of becoming divine, i.
Are we, as some people think, witnessing the beginning of a new Middle Ages and one far more barbarous than the former, for though it practiced realism, it did not extol realismfrom which, however, will arise a new Renaissance, a new return bendda the religion of distinterestedness? All humanity including julien benda treason of the intellectuals “clerks,” have ju,ien laymen.
Perhaps some coolness of mind was needed to recognize that right remained right, even when thus invested with force. This edition is introduced by Roger Kimball. However, if a clerc intends to be used by political “realists” or for practical policy, it is necessarily a failure. Jun 10, Raimo Wirkkala rated it julien benda treason of the intellectuals liked it.
La Nouvelle Trahison des Clercs
And if the juluen of our realists ever came to think of them, I think there is every possibility that it might prohibit them. And this brings us to the question of freedom. Of course, the attack on distinctions that Finkielkraut castigates takes place not only among cultures but also within a given culture.
For today, in the United States anyway, only the title of the book, not its argument, enjoys julien benda treason of the intellectuals currency. Who is going to protect humanity from its own stupidity, greed, its dangerous narrow national interests and wrong choices?
The man of science, the artist, the philosopher are attached to their nations oc much as the day-laborer and the merchant. Looking at history, we may say in a more synthetic manner that, with the exception of two or three very jjlien, luminous epochs whose light, like that of certain intelldctuals, lightens the trewson long after they are extinct, humanity lives generally in darkness; while literatures live generally in a state of decadence and the organism in disorder.
The problem here is that it is claimed reasonable to place blame on the intellectual for their social interpretation regardless of their goal. Buy From Transaction Publishers Amazon. Retrieved from ” https: They were non-materialistic knowledge-see Julien Benda’s classic study of s Europe resonates today.
The real damage done by a man like Trump is that julien benda treason of the intellectuals incites all around him to forget entirely that there are such things as ideals. In the US and Canada universities go further: What Finkielkraut has understood with admirable clarity is that modern attacks on elitism represent not the extension but the destruction intelledtuals culture.